On the Idea Wall · ▲ 2 votes
ClosedLoop — the spec
ClosedLoop is a SaaS accounting platform for internal finance teams that collapses the general ledger, month-end close, and AP/AR payments into one system. The core premise: because every payment and invoice posts directly to the double-entry ledger the moment it happens, the close is never a reconciliation exercise — it is already done.
---
Decisions locked
| Question | Answer |
|---|---|
| Product shape | SaaS web application |
| Audience | Internal finance team |
| Core loop | User runs month-end close and finds zero reconciliation gaps to chase |
| v1 success metric | 10 team members using the platform every week within 30 days |
---
The core loop
- A vendor invoice or customer payment enters the system — keyed manually, uploaded, or pulled from a connected bank feed.
- The unified double-entry ledger posts the debit and credit immediately; no import, no staging table.
- The team member opens the month-end close view; all transactions already appear against their chart-of-accounts lines.
- The system flags any entry that is unposted, unmatched, or outside tolerance — the list is short because the ledger has been live all month.
- The team member clears the flags, locks the period, and the close is complete.
---
v1 scope
Unified double-entry ledger
Every transaction — AP bill, AR invoice, payment, journal entry — posts a balanced debit/credit pair to the same ledger in real time. This is the single source of truth; no other system holds authoritative balances. Lives on the Ledger and Journal Entry screens.
---
Deliberately later
The following features are scoped to v2 and beyond. Each earns its place once the core ledger has proven its integrity under real load.
- Real-time AP approval and payment execution — approval workflows introduce role and permission complexity that belongs on top of a proven ledger, not inside it at launch.
- Automatic bank and card reconciliation sync — feed integrations with US and Canadian financial institutions require partner agreements and exception-handling logic; adds little value until the ledger is trusted.
- Multi-entity consolidation for close — inter-company eliminations and consolidated reporting are a Layer 2 concern; the single-entity close must be clean first.
- Audit trail and workflow enforcement rules — immutable audit logs and segregation-of-duties rules are compliance features that follow after the data model is stable.
- US and Canada tax compliance templates — HST/GST, sales tax nexus, and payroll tax mapping require jurisdiction-specific maintenance; scope after the transaction layer is solid.
- AR aging and invoice collection dashboard — useful analytics, but downstream of having reliable AR data in the ledger for at least one full cycle.
- Close checklist with variance alerts — high value once teams have a baseline period to compare against; premature in month one.
---
Data model sketch
users— id, name, email, role, team_id, created_ataccounts— id, code, name, type (asset/liability/equity/revenue/expense), currency, entity_idjournal_entries— id, entry_date, description, period_id, created_by, status (draft/posted/locked)journal_lines— id, journal_entry_id, account_id, debit_amount, credit_amount, currency, fx_ratetransactions— id, type (bill/invoice/payment/manual), counterparty_id, amount, currency, status, linked_journal_entry_idcounterparties— id, name, type (vendor/customer), country (US/CA), payment_detailsperiods— id, entity_id, year, month, status (open/closed/locked), closed_by, closed_atentities— id, name, country, base_currency, chart_of_accounts_template
---
Screens
- Dashboard — real-time snapshot of open periods, unposted entries, and outstanding transactions requiring attention.
- Ledger — paginated, filterable view of all posted journal lines by account and date range; the authoritative balance view.
- Journal Entry — form for creating and editing manual journal entries with inline debit/credit validation before posting.
- Transactions — list of all bills, invoices, and payments with their posting status and linked journal entry.
- Transaction Detail — single transaction view showing the generated journal lines, counterparty, and edit/void actions.
- Month-End Close — period-level view listing all open items, unmatched entries, and a one-click lock action once the list is clear.
- Settings — chart of accounts management, user roles, entity configuration, and currency preferences.
---
How to use this document
- Bring it into Mind Palace, where the guided platform and its AI coach pick up from exactly this document and build the product with you step by step.
- Hand it to a developer as the complete v1 brief — scope, data model, and screen list are all here.
- Keep it as the single source of truth while you build, so every feature decision can be checked against what is locked above.
This is Manoj's. Build yours.
A spec like this is step 3 of Mind Palace's nine — the other six take a weekend: working software, a real offer, first customers.
Want to build this with Manoj?
Tell us who you are and we'll broker the introduction — their contact details stay private until they say yes.